And all of this took place before the rebellion was even focused on overthrowing the Targs and putting a Baratheon on the throne. There was clearly some conspiracy/ambition, at least if Barbrey has even a nugget of truth. But the witch is not to be trusted and while she brings him back to life, he is only a shadow of the man he was. besides, I dont think grown men are fostered out and it'd be strange if Ned and Robert became so close in only 3 years even when they were travelling outside of the Vale heading in different directions. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company. It is of English and Hebrew origin, and the meaning of Jon is "God is gracious; gift of God". Robert'sbrothers and alliesclash with his incestuous, scheming former allies, House Lannister, while those with a less legitimate claim to power operate in the shadows. This is not exactly right. News and discussions relating to George R. R. Martin's "A Song of Ice and Fire" novels, his Westeros-based short stories, the "Game of Thrones" and "House of the Dragon" TV series, and all things ASOIAF - but with particular emphasis on the written series. A match between Catelyn and Oberyn certainly would have been an intriguing one. Until Littlefinger that is. Transporting School Children / Bigger Cargo Bikes or Trailers. But Lady Catelyn wasn't always a Stark. King Aerys Targaryen II was not called "The Mad King" for nothing, after all. Just asking about when Robert started there, nothing about "Southron Ambitions" or rebellions. And what about the mission--was that sabotaged too? Jon Arryn seems to have done nothing untoward with Robert or Eddard, and viewed them as his own adopted sons, especially after their fathers died and he lost his own heirs one by one. The best thin Jon could have done would have benn to never tell anyone, which is identical to not telling him. And this is when Denys died. It doesn't appear that Highgarden or Dorne was in on it, but one can't be sure. I am not sure how Arryn reacted to the murder of the little Targs nor how he managed to appease Dorne, but obviously Ned knew and this might be a reason why he never told him in the first place. With House Baratheon angered by Lyanna's abduction and House Stark now down three members, a powerful alliance was formed that sought to wrestle control of the Seven Kingdoms from the Targaryens. Can't children that are fostered away visit their parents? Jon Snow takes off to Castle Black as Ygritte shoots arrows at him, which is why these two land in our number 5 spot. Background checks for UK/US government research jobs, and mental health difficulties. Was the ship sabotaged? At 8 I don't think a rebellion is being planned. Is any of the members of the small council announced to chair the small council and to serve as the King's proxy during his absence (powers that would otherwise rest with the Hand of the King)? News and discussions relating to George R. R. Martin's "A Song of Ice and Fire" novels, his Westeros-based short stories, the "Game of Thrones" and "House of the Dragon" TV series, and all things ASOIAF - but with particular emphasis on the written series. His treason/betrayal is his alone. As soon as that was done Littlefinger pushed her out her own moon door, therefore, securing his own place as Lord of the Vale. I don't think Ned (or Benjen) truly ever told anyone. Which makes sense considering Ned and Robert are both there. Small Council had following members at the time: Any monarch would think twice before leaving his city in hands of other men but this small council was divided and thus was of no apparent threat to the King. It's generally accepted that the death of Jon Arryn is the spark that signals the beginning of the Game of Thrones. RELATED:Game Of Thrones: 10 Sam Tarly Memes That Will Have You Cry-Laughing. Theon was used in this manner, but it was a perfectly normal practice for high born. An unlikely couple to be sure, a eunuch member of the Unsullied and Daenerys most trusted counselor, but their short-yet-sweet love story is one that still warms our hearts to this day. Jon Snow was a beloved character on Game of Thrones. Lord Ned Stark khawatir dengan laporan yang mengganggu dari seorang buronan We don't have any record of him attending the tourney at Harrenhal. RELATED:Game of Thrones: How Each Character Is Supposed To Look. I think they would all have basically been fine with Rheagar on the Iron Throne. It exposes them to other lords and customs. Well, I think Edmure is about 10 years younger than Ned, so perhaps plans for him would be some kind of 2nd phase. Jon is also used in the French fashion, hyphenated with another name. Ned accepts (and now has to find Jon a home. While they may no longer reign over their wintry kingdom, they will forever reign over our hearts as Game of Thrones cutest couple. They shared five children together, plus Jon Snow who was allegedly Neds from a mistress, but who we eventually found out was not Neds at all. As someone else said, Edmure was young and Blackfish uncooperative. Ned denies him. I would say that it was the small council that ran Seven Kingdoms in Roberts absence. In Game of Thrones, Robert's Rebellion takes place long before episode 1, but still has major ramifications later. Relationships: Myrcella Baratheon/Bran Stark; Cersei Lannister/Ned Stark; Catelyn Tully Stark/Ned Stark Jon Arryn was like a second father to me and someone murdered him. You're absolutely right. Was Jon Arryn as honorable and noble as everyone believed or was Jon Arryn a Machiavellian plotter who is deceitful and honorless behind Robert rebellion and a anti-Targaryen who was as power hungry as Tywin ? J on as a boys' name is pronounced jahn. @TLP To be fair, it was the small council that ran the Seven Kingdoms in Robert's presence, too. Perhaps Arryn, Baratheon, Stark and Tully had some plan to make their presence felt at court and have their concerns heeded? Yes, it doesnt get much messier than using your spouse for murder then killing them yourself. Was Jon Arryn capable as the Hand? 5 kingdoms started marrying/building relations between themselves (The North, The Riverlands, The Vale, The Stromland and The Westerlands). Honestly, I'm not sure what would have changed in the story. Jon fostered Eddard Stark and Robert Baratheon as his wards in The Vale of Arryn. an anti-Targaryen plot if the purpose of this tourney was to figure out how to put Rhaegar on the throne. Ygritte was a sword-yielding rebel of a wild woman, and as it turned out, just Jons type. We do not know. Maybe around that time when the king was mad they started talking, maybe. (Spoilers Extended). WebJonathan "Jon" Jafari (born 24 March 1990), more commonly known on the internet as JonTron, is an entertainer the co-founder and former co-host of the show Game Grumps, alongside his friend Arin Hanson. It instills a mutual understanding between lords and children, and should conflict erupt, it is an easier means to an end. By That's what I keep hearingby those accounts shouldn't have Edmure have been there as well? Sansa Stark Chapter 22: 20. It's possible he could have wanted years later to tell key people what had happened but not right after Jon was born and as he was traveling from the Tower of Joy. Hoster Tully and his daughters weren't there. House Tully does not enter the picture for a decade. At this point, Robert Baratheon was Lord of the Stormlands, andhad been lined up to marry a woman from another noble house, Lyanna Stark. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. Den enklaste jonen r protium (en vtejon, en positiv laddningsenhet, H + ). They cheated on each other, and lied to each other but would always come back to each other in the end. Were both Ned and Robert that wild such that they could not be raised in their own respective houses? He didn't exactly rise in rebellion when his own nephew and heir was murdered by the Mad King. I agree, plenty of reasons to foster. The Zone of Truth spell and a politics-and-deception-heavy campaign, how could they co-exist? Robert and Ned's fathers along with Jon Arryn were all veterans of the War of the Ninepenny Kings. Sam is awarded the role of Grand Maester on Brandon Starks court and he and Gilly by all accounts live happily ever after. What caused and whattranspired during Robert's Rebellion inGame of Thrones? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. While Southron Ambitions is the overriding reason, it's important to keep in mind that Ned wasn't the heir to the North at that point. And he didn't marry his way into the alliance until after the war had started, and even that came about only after the next heir after Elbert, Denys Arryn, was killed at the Battle of the Bells and then Denys' infant son died as well. The two finally find the acceptance in each other that they could never find out in the world. Jon Snow Chapter 19: 17. Jon would probably be pulled all over the place. When Tyrion went on trial for the murder of his nephew Joffrey, Shae appeared as a witness, claiming Tyrion had been violent towards her and even kidnapped her. And as a daughter of a High Lord, Catelyn's hand in marriage was an incredibly valuable asset, made all that more valuable by Catelyn's intelligence and honor. Gilly had not had the easiest of lives before meeting Sam. The murder of the Hand of the King brings Ned Stark to King's Landing as Robert's new right-hand man. However, Lyanna was seemingly kidnapped by Prince Rhaegar Targaryen (Aerys' eldest son) and whisked away to the faraway locale of Dorne, despite having a wife of his own in Elia Martell. Not sure about the whereabouts of Renly though. I think Robert was at the Vale as a young man. When the rebellion began it was already set and locked that the Vale, the North, and the Stormlands were going to work together in order to overthrow the king. Variant of John or short form of Jonathan. Jon was well known for his honor, and Catelyn would have undoubtedly made a spectacular Lady of the Vale, as well as a wife of the Hand to the King. Finally, Joffrey is poisoned at his own wedding and the little tyrants reign comes to an end, but not before finding a special place in our Game of Thrones worst relationships countdown. Amamos lo que hacemos y nos encanta poder seguir construyendo y emprendiendo sueos junto a ustedes brindndoles nuestra experiencia de ms de 20 aos siendo pioneros en el desarrollo de estos canales! He was married at least twice before and failed to produce an heir. He was at Harrenhal. Later? That's why LF was fostered at Riverrun. Absolutely about the marriage angle. There had been no official treason launched, Aerys was just a paranoid nutcase and Rhaegar was a prophecy-obsessed sad boy. PAVALCO TRADING nace con la misin de proporcionar soluciones prcticas y automticas para la venta de alimentos, bebidas, insumos y otros productos en punto de venta, utilizando sistemas y equipos de ltima tecnologa poniendo a su alcance una lnea muy amplia deMquinas Expendedoras (Vending Machines),Sistemas y Accesorios para Dispensar Cerveza de Barril (Draft Beer)as comoMaquinas para Bebidas Calientes (OCS/Horeca), enlazando todos nuestros productos con sistemas de pago electrnicos y software de auditora electrnica en punto de venta que permiten poder tener en la palma de su mano el control total de su negocio. Rhaegar acted unexpectedly, and Aerys' murder of Brandon and Rickard gave the perfect excuse to start the war to depose Aerys. So while Shae may never have wrangled herself a spot on the throne, she did wrangle one on our countdown. Whether she left willingly or not doesn't matter; it's not something that's done either way. MOLPRO: is there an analogue of the Gaussian FCHK file? A second son of a High Lord is a perfect match for am heiress of a Lord Paramount position. Robert's Father was dead, and Robert was Lord of the Stormlands. I don't think there's any anti-Targaryen plot going on between anyone at any time and that the idea of southron ambition is 100%overstated. As for parentage, Robb's parents died when he was very young in ship breaker bay as he watched. I think it said Robert and Stannis watched their parents die, right? Kids: Robyn Arryn . Ned has no idea how accepted Robert's reign will be and what will happen with support for the Targaryens. IF ever it could be said that a non-regal child was born more politically powerful than the child of a king, it would have been said about all of the Stark children, for they were born between two noble houses, as opposed to being born of just one (as most Targaryens are). Basically, the two died in the rubble of the city and the lives they destroyed. Jon didn't turn anti-Targ until Aerys murdered his heir, Elbert, and then demanded Ned and Robert as well. It has some grounds, and is probably one of the reasons Ned was fostered South. It seems Rickard Stark, Jon Arryn, Steffon Baratheon and Hoster Tully met at the War of the Ninepenny Kings and became really close friends and then decided to strengthen those ties by fostering and betrothing their children. Jon's heir was still Denys Arryn when he got married. Renly was charming but he did not particularly get on with Stannis and harbored his own ambitions of wedding Robert to Lord Tyrell's daughter Margaery. Then Neds wardship was more as a gesture of goodwill and alliance building, mentioned before when lady Dustin states that lord Rickard had southron ambitions, so building an alliance without marriage like with Brandon and later lyanna is very cost effective. I have not heard that before. Why did King Aerys demand the death of Robert Baratheon and Eddard Stark? It's Barbry Dustin talking shit. Tyrion Lannister Chapter 21: 19. Maquinas Vending tradicionales de snacks, bebidas, golosinas, alimentos o lo que tu desees. They wed, bore a child (the famous Jon Snow) and the truth was only discovered when Ned and his close friend, Howland Reed, finally found Lyanna at the Tower of Joy. Winterfell Resident, January 8, 2014 in General (ASoIaF), After reading all 5 books of "A Song of Ice and Fire", I know that Ned Stark and Robert Baratheon were both fostered by Jon Arryn. It is also possible that Council may have been acting as a combined body acting through popular vote. Is every feature of the universe logically necessary? Food, trade, protection, marriages War is the exception here, it just so happened that it ended that way. These are 10 characters in the series that Cat should have been with, besides Ned. I would appreciate it, if someone has a sense as to why both Ned and Robert were fostered by Jon Arryn, to please reply with their. I feel like if he knew he would have counseled to get rid of the kid farther, hide him in the Vale if he has to say hes his bastard. Performance Regression Testing / Load Testing on SQL Server. Site Maintenance - Friday, January 20, 2023 02:00 - 05:00 UTC (Thursday, Jan What is the meaning of "The seed is strong"? Would Jon Arryn keep the secret - not knowing who else might know about Rhaegar's remaining son? He lives in New Hampshire with his wife Rebecca and two daughters. Il a galement un frre cadet, Benjen, qui est le chef des patrouilleurs de la Garde de Nuit.. Dans sa jeunesse, Eddard Stark et son ami Robert Baratheon sont forms au maniement des armes par Jon Arryn, pour qui les deux jeunes hommes ont un profond respect. He peered in as he saw his father, Eddard Stark, and the queen, Cersei Lannister, both fully naked as the day they were born. But then grownup Sam came to change her fate and made her his wife and brought her along on his adventures. Selmy was too noble for court intrigue. He had it all made, but had to throw it all away by doing something stupid over a pretty girl. There is a reason Ned did not tell him. She can't just elope, and Rhaegar can't abduct her even if he is a prince. It is clear that King Robert was more interested in hunting and whoring than in ruling the kingdom and therefore let the small council run the realm in his stead. As already suggested, it was the Small council which ruled in Robert's presence as well so it would not have been particularly difficult for the members to act without a formal hand or King to preside their proceedings. While there were many relationships in Game of Thrones, these are a few that really stand out in our minds from the cute to the cringe, from the toxic to the tumultuous, from the aww to the awful, and everything in between. Watching the romance of timid Jon Snow and wildfire Ygritte unfold before our eyes, was almost as exciting as watching Jaime get his hand cut off, but you know, a lot less gross. I think Lord Arryn would keep his mouth shut, but it would be extremely distracting thinking about it while serving Robert. We don't know what Lyanna made him promise. My guess is that he was not the mastermind, just a willing part of the conspiracy (unlike Robert and Steffon). Now who does Robert name Hand? It's kind of hard to say how involved Jon was in any anti-Targ conspiracy before the rebellion. But with his outwardly charming ways and golden boy good looks, plus that whole next-in-line to be king thing, he was able to woo Sansa. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Variations But all the relationships of Westeros were not created equal and some were clearly more healthy than others. Cant send him to The Vale, now) and stays in KL. Westeros: The 'A Song of Ice and Fire' Domain A tragic ending for a tragically gross couple. Either Hoster Tully is a faithless asshole (which he kind of is an asshole anyway with or without that) or there was no plotting going on with Jon Arryn to begin with. It can be either handed over as a sign of trust or to forge an alliance, but the underlying principle of we can't mess with these guys or we lose an heir is always there. In exchange, Daenerys offers up her unborn child in a blood magic ritual to bring Khal Drogo back. Also, what would be the point in telling him? But again, this is not necessarily an anti-Targaryen plot if the purpose of this tourney was to figure out how to put Rhaegar on the throne. They connected through marriage alliances. She was born Catelyn Tully, the eldest daughter of Hoster Tully, the Lord of Riverrun and Warden of the Riverlands. Though Ned chose to follow traditions and what was expected of him, there was no denying the capital was a dangerous place. Jump to Chapter Chapter 1: Chapter 18: 16. We don't know a lot about Jon Arryn at the end of the day, but Ned pretty deliberately tried to distance himself from Is it safe to say that Robert went at age 6-8, the same range of time that Sweetrobin and Ned were sent? Eventually, Grey Worm sailed off with his people to Naath, Missandeis homeland, and Missandei was beheaded by the Mountain under Cerseis orders. The sudden boom in interregional marriages (a la Stark/Tully) that presented itself post-WotNK made me consider rigourously the properties (first socio-political, then magical) of the resultant offspring. I don't think there ever was an anti-Targ conspiracy, so much as it was a matter of the great Houses figuring out the Targs needed them more than they needed the Targs. Movie News, Movie Trailers & upcoming Movie Reviews, The Leading Source for Gaming News, Reviews, and Interviews, Game of Thrones: Why Ned Stark and Robert Baratheon Rebelled, Why Game of Thrones Recast Daario Naharis in Season 4, Game of Thrones: The Problem With The Night King's Season 8 Plan, Stranger Things: 10 Quotes That Perfectly Sum Up Eddie As A Character, 10 Best TV Shows Like Hulu's Tell Me Lies, Grey's Anatomy: 10 Derek Shepherd Plot Holes That Make No Sense, The Vampire Diaries: Elena's 10 Cringiest Parts (According To Reddit), House Of The Dragon: Targaryen Rulers, Ranked From Least To Most Competent, The 45 Best Sitcoms Of All Time (According To IMDb), Friends Star Matthew Perry Begged Writers To Change One Chandler Detail, Wil Wheatons Cameo Mistake Is One Of His Favorite Big Bang Theory Moments, Big Bang Theory Boss Admits Huge Penny Mistake In Early Seasons. Like Robb, Jon inherited Neds traits of honor and duty. (Spoilers Main) POV: You are Robert Baratheon. Mya was born in 280 AC. Ned and Robert were in love early on and went for a break. It has never been confirmed at what age Robert went to foster with Jon Arryn, correct? Well, there is the Southern Ambitions theory that Rickard Stark, Jon Arryn, Hoster Tully and Steffon Baratheon were possibly making a grand alliance. Whatever it was, Ned's sense of honor would have prevented him from roping anyone else into his lie. The risk was too great, and they knew it would inevitably lead to Jon's death. He clearly made a difference, not like Cat, but still. It could go a few different ways from there. As for Baratheon--he was entrusted with a sensitive mission to Essos--to find a bride for the crown prince. Aerys' Hand, Tywin Lannister, had no great regard for the Night's Watch, hence its neglect for several generations, which would have worried the Starks. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. I'd be interested to see your sources. Jon Arryn didn't have any children to marry, so to help bring Jon into the alliance Rob and Ned were sent to be fostered there. I think it would have weighed heavily on Jon. Sansa and Joffrey get engaged, but as soon as Sansas father Ned dies, Joffreys true colors shine through. Powered by Invision Community. There is a theory that has become pretty widely accepted, I believe, that the North and most of the South at this point was building an anti-Targaryan (or at least anti-Aerys) alliance. Tully, in any case, would have had to remain on good terms with all his neighbors--hence the need for alliances with the North and the Westerlands, and failing that, the Vale. Ned makes perfect sense, he being the 2nd born son, having no claim to WF while Brandon was still alive. The fostering of children and heirs of great houses is another means to build relations and alliances amongst various houses without the commitment of marriage. Would the War of the Five Kings have occurred if Ned had refused Robert's request? So in doing so, Littlefinger secured himself and Lysa a spot as one of the least healthy relationships Game of Thrones has to offer. OR "Keep him safe, love him, because he has no one else" OR "Don't let them use him to take the Iron Throne.". Yeah he can't rule Winterfell but the second son of The Lord of Winterfell could wed perhaps a lord that has only daughters. "Please don't let Robert kill him Ned." It would have sparked questions. Aided by other rebel houses, Robert Baratheon and Ned Stark led a war lasting approximately a year. He'd be shocked then nothing will really happen. This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies. Today I realised that 'milk of the poppy' is just poppy (spoilers main) Ser Kevan might be one of the most well (SPOILERS PUBLISHED) Bran is a much darker character than (Spoilers Extended) The lack of a wealthy, urban [Spoilers Extended] Why the fandom likes Stannis so much? Well, according to Barbrey Dustin and Euron Greyjoy, the maesters had a long term "Southern Ambitions" strategy going on. Are the models of infinitesimal analysis (philosophically) circular? Tous deux sont dj morts au dbut de la saga. He raised him as one of his own, with warmth and equal privileges. And amongst his wards, for whatever reason, Robert seems his favorite. Robert's parents were dead. As to Robert being home at that moment being coincidental nothing strange about Robert learning of when his parents would return home and making sure he would be at Storm's End at that time as well. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. Rhaegar acted unexpectedly, and Aerys' murder of Brandon and Rickard gave the perfect excuse to start the war to depose Aerys. Search. Ick. Det vill sga att den inte har lika mnga elektroner som protoner. King Aerys was controversially killed by Jaime Lannister, and Robert himself claimed the throne, since he was the man to rebel first and he had bested Rhaegar in battle. And yes, he and Stannis were watching as the storm ripped their parent's ships appart. Westeros: The 'A Song of Ice and Fire' Domain, A Song of Ice and Fire 2024 Calendar Announced, Game of Thrones Official Fan Convention Tickets on Sale Now, Wrapping Up on House of the Dragon Season 1, GRRM Donates to Northwestern University, Endows a New Chair, Game of Thrones Complete Collection (Blu-Ray). Pycelle was all alone. They may not have spoken the same language, but somehow they seemed to understand each other perfectly, with long lingering touches, and smoldering glances; plus, their steamy language lessons helped too. Fostering is not uncommon among the Lords of Westeros. Brandon was fostered in the North. Generally it's political reasons, it's also good fo Quentyn Martell, on the other hand, was fostered at an absurd early age, because Doran needed to make peace with the Yronwoods. Brandon was still alive and healthy. Doran needed to pay the blood price to clean up after Oberyn's idiocy. ` I don't really buy the Southron Ambitions theory. So yes, the most toxic award goes to Stannis Baratheon and Melisandre. 2) Se says that his seed was weak. And Ned would have sent back defiance (great line from Books) and massed at Moat Callin. Now, magically I can't really say that these hybrid kids gain anything, but can we at least recognize that the gods themselves may have been perplexed in doling out the quintessential qualities which make a Stark a Stark and a Tully a Tully (assuming that divine intervention is considered to be at least part of what imbues the ruling houses with their power)? This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies. Nuestras mquinas expendedoras inteligentes completamente personalizadas por dentro y por fuera para su negocio y lnea de productos nicos. "We have your bloodline, step out of line and we can end it." Remember, Littlefinger's father also fought in that war, saving Hoster's life, if I recall correctly. Jon Arryn didn't have any children to marry, so to help bring Jon into the alliance Rob and Ned were sent to be fostered there. Of course, there was an untold, yet vital, chapter in these events. Quentyn Martell was the ward of Lord Yronwood. As the title asks, why were Robert Baratheon and Ned Stark wards of Jon Arryn? So I don't think anything else would have been different. Also not that many people were involved in the plot, that was the point of the tourney, to bring everybody in.